We Need Bold Moves To Stem The Tide Of Poverty.
By Editorial
THE PREVAILING perception about our local poverty problem
isn't covered by the saying that the proverbial glass is either
half full or half empty. Because when it comes to poverty, for
years many people in Tucson seem to have asked, "What glass?"
The extent of poverty here is staggering. Statistics show that
in 1990 Tucson had the highest percentage of its population living
below the federal poverty level of any major city in the state.
The local rate was 40 percent higher than Phoenix, considerably
above both Flagstaff and Yuma, and more than double the rate in
Mesa.
Those statistics also showed that Tucson's median household income
was by far the lowest of any of these communities. The figures
may be eight years old now, but there's no reason to think they've
changed, except for the worse.
The simple fact is, Tucson is Arizona's poorest major community.
Today there are almost 100,000 people within the city limits living
in poverty. The chances of them escaping this condition seem to
be getting worse, not better. That's because many of the jobs
created recently are minimum-wage or part-time positions.
Tucson didn't achieve this embarrassing status overnight. It
has been decades in the making, and due in large part to incompetent,
short-sighted community and business leaders intent on having
the most jobs possible, no matter what they paid. If this sounds
like an indictment of past practices and business-as-usual in
Tucson, it is.
We as a community have accomplished something special: We have
very low unemployment, but a poverty-burdened population living
in the middle of a quickly disappearing scenic wonderland.
It wasn't always this way--we took a wrong turn somewhere along
the line years ago. And if we don't change things, if we don't
find the right path, things will go from bad to terrible.
But at least a few positive things are happening. When the City
Council finally holds a study session on reducing poverty, perhaps
this month, it will have taken a long-awaited first step in addressing
this devastating situation.
It's been two years since the Council first agreed to discuss
the issue. While the uncountable delays in holding this meeting
are inexcusable, at least by having the study session the Council
will be acknowledging that a serious poverty problem exists.
THE CITY COUNCIL has paid only minor attention to reducing
poverty in the past, as when it considered the well-intentioned
but ill-conceived and self-serving jobs-training program proposed
by the Pima County Interfaith Council. But more must be done--much
more.
The first step must be holding the study session on reducing
poverty as soon as possible.
The Council, the Pima County Board of Supervisors, business leaders,
the media, the folks in the suburbs and the public in general
must recognize the scope of the issue. This isn't a southside
or a central-city problem, it isn't a minority problem, and it
isn't a single-parent household problem. It's a Tucson problem.
Then the community needs to agree, quickly, on a comprehensive
plan to attack the low wages paid in this town. That will take
political courage from our elected leaders, something they're
not known for. But it must be done. They'll have to step on some
well-established toes to do it, but there isn't any other choice.
The plan for reducing poverty should have several components.
Local governments can get involved by reducing subsidies paid
to attract growth and to encourage annexations. They can get out
of the tourism-promotion business.
The City of Tucson could set the example by paying all of its
permanent employees at least $8 an hour and requiring anyone who
does business with the city to do the same. The City Council can
also take the lead in increasing funding for the Greater Tucson
Economic Council. GTEC might not be perfect in what it does, but
it's the best we have going for us.
The business community, which spent tons of money defeating the
minimum-wage initiative in November, should now devote its energies
to raising Tucson's wage rate. Pushing Republicans in the state
Legislature to provide more spending on childcare, nutrition and
transportation programs for the job-hunting poor while fairly
equalizing school district funding would be steps in the right
direction.
Also, Tucson's educational system must change. Too many dropouts,
too few people with skills needed by higher-paying firms, and
too much blithering political correctness in the classroom must
end.
But the most important part of this plan must include the individual
and the family. Without their efforts to encourage education,
push for higher wages, oppose crime while supporting community
improvement projects, and without their demands for accountability
and leadership from elected officials, not much is going to change.
Poverty and low wages are an inbred and persistent problem in
Tucson. The issue must be acknowledged, addressed, and reduced--starting
now. Change won't happen quickly, but it must happen. Because
the alternative is scary.
An ever-increasing number of low-paying jobs, women and children
begging on street medians and more poverty-driven crime are simply
unacceptable.
This is not a future we can tolerate. Nobody will be able to
escape the reality of an ever-poorer Tucson. At least by holding
its poverty reduction study session, the City Council will begin
a discussion which might help prevent us from growing even poorer
tomorrow.
|