Bruce Babbitt Comes To Town To Support The Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan.
By Jim Nintzel
INTERIOR SECRETARY Bruce Babbitt still has a pretty good
understanding of Pima County, even though he said good-bye to
Arizona politics more than a decade ago.
"There is something really unique about this town,"
Babbitt said in a special meeting before the Pima County Board
of Supervisors last Thursday, December 3. "It's a feisty,
bold, contentious, litigious, sometimes outrageous place, and
of course it's precisely that quality of activism and active concern
about the community that is so special about Tucson and brings
us here today."
Babbitt had come to Pima County to endorse the Sonoran Desert
Conservation Plan, a feisty, bold and contentious proposal designed
to preserve unspoiled tracts of desert wilderness while directing
development in less-sensitive areas.
Under the proposal, Pima County will develop, in conjunction
with state and federal agencies, a multi-species habitat conservation
plan, which would create a framework for dealing with endangered-species
concerns before they reach a crisis point, as the Amphi School
District is now facing in its battle to build a new high school
in prime habitat for the endangered pygmy owl.
The stage for Babbitt's visit was set last August, when a coalition
of environmental groups working with the county to design a conservation
plan agreed to drop its opposition to working under Section 10
of the Endangered Species Act, which deals with the distribution
of permits that allow the "taking" of endangered animals.
The coalition had opposed developing a multi-species habitat conservation
plan because it was critical of the similar plans developed in
other Southwestern communities, including San Diego.
A key architect of that controversial San Diego plan was longtime
U.S. Fish and Wildlife staffer Gail Kobetich, who has been lured
out of retirement to serve as Babbitt's liaison as Pima County
puts together its plan. County officials hope Kobetich's experience
will accelerate the plan's development.
Babbitt also announced the Interior Department was prepared to
split the upfront costs of developing the plan. But county officials
are hoping for more: With a price tag that ranges from $250 million
to a half-billion dollars over the next two decades, implementation
of the Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan promises to be impossible
for Pima County to afford on its own. Already, county staff is
making an effort to acquire some of the state dollars available
through the recently passed Growing Smarter initiative.
But even those funds, matched by open-space bond dollars, will
fall far short of the massive acquisition costs proposed by county
staff, who are quietly hoping the feds will provide the high level
of funding available to other multi-species habitat conservation
plans.
As Babbitt noted at the meeting, Pima County has two congressmen
who can help in this effort: Rep. Jim Kolbe sits on the subcommittee
that controls appropriations for the Interior Department, while
Rep. Ed Pastor has a seat on the Energy and Water Development
subcommittee. In addition, Sen. Jon Kyl recently landed a seat
on the all-powerful Senate Appropriations Committee.
But every silver lining has a dark cloud--and that dark cloud
appeared on the horizon the day after Babbitt's visit, when the
Tucson Citizen revealed that Babbitt's visit was motivated
by a request from legendary land speculator Don Diamond.
Supervisor Sharon Bronson, who has been a strong proponent of
developing the multi-species habitat conservation plan, said she
thought Diamond's influence on the process had been overstated.
"It's my understanding what made the Secretary committed
to this is that we had both sides cooperating," Bronson says.
"We had developers working with environmentalists and small
property owners. It was situation where folks wanted to accomplish
something rather than head for the courts."
But Supervisor Raul Grijalva, who has been more skeptical of
the multi-species habitat conservation plan, said he was troubled
by Diamond's involvement.
"We have had this community-generated call to do something,"
Grijalva says. "Once Diamond gets into the picture, it brings
a whole different taint. And the taint is, 'What's in for it me?'
And I hope that as we look at prime acquisition, all of sudden
those kinds of property don't become the thing. or we don't end
accommodating and compromising with Don when this has been driven
by the community up until this point."
|