The Big Bad University Of Arizona Muscles Small Merchants On Sixth Street--But There's Hope.
By Dave Devine
IT CAN BE hell trying to keep a small business alive in
Tucson. And perhaps the lowest rung of small-business hell in
the Baked Pueblo is located south of the University of Arizona
campus along Sixth Street.
The merchants here have had to endure 25 years of government
assault. In the late 1960s, the City of Tucson started plopping
cones in the street during rush hour to speed traffic flow. This
move cut off most commuters' access to the businesses during peak
hours.
A few years later, city bureaucrats banned parking on Sixth during
peak driving hours. Then they banned parking all together. While
the bureaucrats held out the promise those precious parking spaces
might be replaced, they never were.
And two years ago, when the traffic cones were finally removed,
the Tucson City Council indicated it wanted to further reduce
traffic volume on Sixth.
Despite all of these insults, the area has continued to serve
the needs of UA students and the general public with an eclectic
mix of ethnic restaurants and other small businesses.
But now comes a potential death blow: UA officials have plans
for the area--plans that will require the two blocks of businesses
on the north side of the street--from Pizza City to Zachary's--to
be torn down.
The good news is that UA officials may try to consolidate businesses
on the south side of Sixth, thus retaining at least some of the
area's uniquely funky business character.
But the University's real focus, of course, is on its own expansion.
Officials plan on building two new projects on the north side
of Sixth. One will be the second phase of the Environmental and
Natural Resources complex. The other project will be yet another
parking garage--a structural genre which seems well on its way
to becoming the architectural signature of the UA.
University bureaucrats originally made a decision to build the
garage on the south side of the street. But during a two-year
cooperative planning effort with neighborhood representatives
and merchants, it was agreed they'd move the garage to the north
side of Sixth.
The destruction of the businesses on the north side would be
in keeping with the conclusions of a University-commissioned commercial
market analysis. The study recommends concentrating businesses
west of the sprawling campus and suggests that "commercial
development in the Sixth Street Corridor be foregone."
But it's not quite bye-bye, pizza pie yet; University officials
may reject that recommendation.
In fact, Bruce Wright, a UA senior officer, has proposed the
school acquire both sides of Sixth, and then relocate the north-side
businesses to the south side. Under his proposal, if there were
not enough space to accommodate all the existing businesses, the
state would construct new buildings.
At the same time, Wright believes parking, streetscape and building
code issues would have to be addressed--items that would require
the city's cooperation. He has also proposed what he believes
is an affordable five-year rent schedule for the relocated businesses.
While admitting a lot of details still have to be worked out,
Wright says he hopes to have a fully realized plan--and possibly
a decision to proceed--by September.
Dave Ellis, owner of Zachary's Pizza and president of the Sixth
Street Merchants Association, says he's encouraged by Wright's
proposal.
But Tom Palliser, Pizza City owner, is not so pleased. He says
stress from the uncertainty over what's going to happen, not to
mention the continual delays in the planning process, is aggravating
a medical condition, and he wants out of the area. He prefers,
he says, the city's northwest side, far away from the UA.
But Palliser is still caught in a waiting game--waiting for the
UA to acquire the building he rents. Palliser is entitled to receive
state relocation assistance because he's being displaced by a
state project. But because UA officials have been very slow in
pursuing the purchase of the building he's in, Palliser is still
having to wait before he can even think about moving. In the meantime,
he says, he's lost staff and sleep.
Palliser is obviously trying not to sound too critical of
the UA officials he's been dealing with, but he has a message
for them: "They should remember," he says, "that
they're not working with small businesses, they're working with
people."
Look for some changes in the area to occur this summer. The old
"new Loft" building will be torn down, and planning
for the street's two new north-side projects will proceed, with
construction of these buildings expected to begin as early as
next year.
It won't seem like the same funky old place, of course; but with
any luck some of the businesses will survive to offset the cold
sterility of that ever-expanding empire of parking garages we
call the UA.
|