'Ten Things,' The Latest Ballyhoo For The Bard, Offers An Enjoyable Twist On The Misogynistic Classic.
By James DiGiovanna
ONE THING BILL Shakespeare was great at was writing teen
films...Romeo and Juliet, West Side Story, that new Romeo
and Juliet, and now 10 Things I Hate About You, which
he adapted from his 1597 play The Taming of The Shrew.
10 Things, on top of having one of the worst film titles
since The Incredibly Strange Creatures Who Stopped Living and
Became Mixed-Up Zombies, is also one of the best Shakespeare
films of the last several weeks.
Why? Well, partly because it takes the Bard's most sexist comedy
and turns it into a post-feminist bash, partly because it stars
the soon-to-be-incredibly-famous Julia Stiles, and partly just
because there's not much else at the theater this week.
10 Things also manages something that Taming of the
Shrew didn't, which is that it's consistently funny for modern
audiences. The scripting is zippy and further enlivened by a sensibility
for the complexities of teenage life that most teen films completely
lack.
While the story is fairly standard teen film fare--boy is secretly
paid to date girl, and winds up falling in love with her--writer
Karen McCullah Lutz (who collaborated with Shakespeare on this
one) understands that most of the teen film clichés simply
don't apply in the real world.
The film starts with new kid Cameron (3rd Rock from the Sun's
Joseph Gordon-Levitt) being shown around Seattle's Padua High
School (fans of the Bard will enjoy this and the many other references
to the original play) by nerdboy Michael. Instead of showing Cameron
a school simplistically divided into "in" and "out"
crowds, as in most teen films, Michael introduces Cameron to a
more complex and realistic social milieu. They weave through a
multitude of cliques, including ska lovers in narrow pants and
pork-pie hats, white Rastas with home-made dreadlocks, future
business-geeks in ugly suits, cowboy kids with Wrangler butts,
and moody coffee addicts jonesing for their morning fix.
However, this is still a teen film: as the new kid, Cameron is
something of an outsider, and therefore must fall for most-popular-girl
Bianca. Bianca, unfortunately, cannot date until her older sister
Kat (Julia Stiles) starts dating. This is unlikely, because, this
being a '90s teen film, Kat is The Angry, Girl-Power Rebel Teen
(see The Rage: Carrie 2, She's All That and the
upcoming Ghost World), and she thinks that all the boys
at her local high school are troglodytes.
Oddly, Stiles, who really tears up the screen here as Kat (and
also in last year's Wicked, which screens at the Arizona
International Film Festival next week) is also set to appear later
this year in O, a teen-film updating of Othello.
Anyway, her dream is to get as far away from Seattle as possible
by heading to the East Coast and going to Sarah Lawrence College.
I've got news for her: I spent a semester at Sarah Lawrence College,
and the few boys there who weren't gay were, in fact, troglodytes.
Of course, that wouldn't matter for Kat since the whole point
of going to Sarah Lawrence College is to go on the four-year lesbian
program, but that's beside the point.
As you would expect, Cameron isn't the only one who wants to
get with Bianca. In fact, pretty much everyone wants to get with
Bianca, and everyone thinks Kat is some kind of psycho-bitch because
she reads Sylvia Plath and spouts lots of overprivileged-white-girl-feminist
stuff and puts on a punk-rock scowl before returning to her suburban
mansion overlooking Puget Sound.
There, her uptight OB/GYN dad, played by Larry Miller at his
most hilarious, uses her anti-social behavior as an excuse to
keep his young daughters from winding up on the wrong side of
the stirrups in his office. His years of delivering teen crack-babies
have convinced him that all dating is bad, and that holding hands
while rollerblading will no doubt lead to the only human condition
commonly delineated into trimesters. He lays down what he thinks
is a no-fail rule to keep Bianca's pants buttoned: she may not
date until Kat does.
Thus, to date Bianca, Cameron must get Kat a date. To do this,
he convinces one of Bianca's other suitors, boy model Joey, to
pay the school's outlaw, Patrick Verona (get it?) to try and whip
Kat into shape...or at least to take her to the movies.
The plot is then fairly standard: Patrick falls in love with
Kat, she falls in love with him, and we wait in dread for the
financial basis of their relationship to be exposed so she can
run off crying and he can try to win her back. Blah blah blah.
Still, 10 Things is pretty successful and has a lot going
for it. It's way smarter than most recent teen films, much funnier,
and it balances out Kat's shallow teenage pretensions to feminism
with a funny and pointed speech by her English teacher (played
sharply by David Leisure), who, being black, figures he's got
more right to feel oppressed than beautiful, wealthy Kat.
Since the film leaves the underlying feminist principles intact,
it's much preferable to the anti-feminist Pygmalion message
of She's All That. 10 Things never pretends that
its protagonist is an ugly girl who just needs a make-over and
a date with a football star to get her past her Betty Friedan
stage. Rather, it explains and validates Kat's political views
through actual encounters with unpleasant patriarchal conditions,
but doesn't elevate them beyond the level of ill-thought out teenage
versions of very real political positions. And there's only one
Australian in the entire film.
10 Things I Hate About You is playing at Catalina
(881-0616), Century Gateway (792-9000) and Foothills
(742-6174) cinemas.
|