Director Joel Schumacher is the only one
who brings some razzle-dazzle to Andrew
Lloyd Webber’s well-known operetta, with
the ho-hum performances,
dirge-filled soundtrack and clichéd plot of
a tortured love triangle. The titular
Phantom (Gerard Butler) no longer is the
grotesque and feared monster like Lon
Chaney’s 1925 version, but a young stud
with chiseled features and a stylized
porcelain mask. Regardless of this
unfortunate deviation, the Phantom still
lurks in the dark catacombs beneath the
Opera House where he tutors a beautiful
opera singer (Emmy Rossum). Soon, the
rising star’s former boyfriend (Patrick
Wilson) returns with his boring and
uncharismatic personality so that
jealousy inevitably can ensue with
laborious dialogue and depressing
songs. However, the director’s visually
appealing translation of this overly
recycled tale stimulates viewers with the
sensational sets, costume and art
direction. This, thankfully, will help
viewers endure this 143-minute musical.